stonemason 2

What Is The Difference Between Granite and Onyx Countertops?

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Choosing the proper countertop material is essential if you want to improve the visual appeal of your kitchen or bathroom. Countertops made of granite or onyx are typically the most expensive and eye-catching choices. 

    We'll compare and contrast these two high-quality options here. After reading this, your decision on how to proceed with your home renovation project will be well-informed.

    Advantages and Disadvantages of Granite Countertops

    Onyx is a popular alternative to marble for home decor because of its natural luxury and the fact that it can be polished to get a marble-like sheen. Over millions of years, its distinctive pattern of clashing colours and rich, parallel strata formed.

    Onyx is beautiful, but its high care requirements and difficult installation mean that it is rarely used in kitchens and bathrooms. Because of its singular appearance, it finds its most widespread application in constructing bar counters.

    If you own a home in Toronto and are debating whether or not to put in an onyx bar countertop, read on. For your consideration are the following benefits and drawbacks.

    The Benefits of Using Onyx as a Bar Countertop 

    Onyx is an excellent choice if you want a bar countertop made of natural stone but also something unique.

    It Looks Great

    Onyx countertops are superior to other natural stone options due to their one-of-a-kind beauty.

    The typical tone of onyx is a pale one. Onyx countertops are versatile and may be found in various colours, including yellow, green, blue, and red. It also comes in lighter, more subtle colours like beige and cream.

    Quartz-like flecks, marble-like veins, and granite-like swirls are just a few of the unique patterns and variances that can be found.

    It Lasts

    Onyx countertops, composed of natural stone, have a lifespan of up to a century with good maintenance. In other words, you won't need to replace it over your lifetime.

    Very Rare

    Unlike other natural stone countertops, Onyx is generated from ground or spring water with lots of calcite. Calcite crystals form a crust on the surface of the spring, where the water emerges when the mineral precipitates. Minerals accumulate when more water runs by and settles them out.

    Differences in water quantity, velocity, and contaminants are responsible for the layered complexity. This method is responsible for giving onyx slabs their distinctive visual appeal. Because of this, it is perfect for individuals who desire a unique countertop.

    It is Translucent

    Onyx's remarkable benefit, its translucence, makes it appear soft to the touch. You may use this quality to your advantage by lighting under the stone to create a backlit bar top. In addition, there is no risk of shadows or hot spots.

    Backlighting may warm and brighten stone tones depending on the spectrum. You won't find this quality in similar materials.

    It's Easy to Carry

    Onyx is frequently employed in decorative contexts because of its lesser weight than other natural stones. Onyx is typically quarried in thin slabs for this very reason. It is less dense than certain other types of stone, making it a good choice for interior and vertical uses.

    Disadvantages of Onyx Bar Countertops

    Its Cost

    Due to its rarity and high demand, onyx is one of the most expensive natural stones for countertops. Because you'll likely need to employ a contractor with experience working with the material, you should expect the cost of labour and installation to be higher. This is necessary to protect the countertop from being harmed during the installation process. In addition, it will be more expensive to fix if it breaks.

    Its Fragility

    Onyx countertops, while beautiful, are delicate and need constant upkeep.

    Despite its similarities to more durable natural stones, its brittleness sets it apart. Fibreglass can be used to reinforce the onyx compound's base, but it may still scratch and shatter easily.

    It's also important to seal the countertop correctly to prevent damage.

    Its Maintenance

    There's more to it than merely dropping in an onyx slab for a bar top. If you plan on using it as a bar top, kitchen counter, or bathroom vanity, seal it first. Additionally, specialised stone cleaning is required to prevent scratches and stains.

    Costs associated with having the countertop refinished regularly should be considered if regular use is planned.

    Using onyx, an exotic natural stone, as a bar countertop may create a stunning statement. There are many different kinds, so you can make a work of art wherever you put it. If you install backlighting behind your onyx bar countertop, it will become the room's focal point.

    The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Granite Countertops

    Plagioclase, Quartz, and alkali feldspar make up the natural stone known as granite. This stone is formed naturally by combining silica and alkali metal oxides in lava, which is then allowed to cool and solidify underground. It occurs predominantly in igneous intrusions on the Earth's crust.

    There are more benefits than drawbacks to having granite countertops in your home.

    Advantages of Granite Countertops

    Granite countertops are prefered because they are long-lasting, hygienic, and aesthetically pleasing. However, the advantages of this common substance still need to be exhausted here.

    Natural Material

    Granite is a natural stone, so unlike other countertop materials like laminate, it has no synthetic resins or additives in its construction.

    Quartz, for example, may be labelled as natural when, in fact, it contains resins and other artificial components. In contrast, every component of granite is of natural origin.

    Natural Appearance

    All granite slabs are one-of-a-kind. Two granite slabs will always be different from one another.

    The natural stone finishings give the space a cosy, opulent feel reminiscent of a Tuscan villa or a French country house.

    Granite may be found in various colours, some darker than others, so if you want to lighten up your kitchen, don't worry.

    Different Patterns

    The nearly infinite possibilities in terms of design are one of granite's biggest benefits.

    Because every slab of granite is one of a kind, it gives homeowners the chance to choose a one-of-a-kind accent for their homes.

    It can be found in a range of pastel to deep tones and always features long, silky veins and tiny specks and grains.

    Slabs come in various colours, from black and white to grey and beige to gold and pink and blue.

    The point is that granite affords a variety of design possibilities. And there's bound to be something that works with the style of your kitchen.

    The abundance of alternatives is bewildering. Shopping for granite, however, is often the most thrilling part of a kitchen redesign for most individuals.

    Heat Resistant

    Granite is not only aesthetically pleasing but also functional. It outperforms quartz and marble in terms of resistance to heat and durability.

    Granite countertops can withstand heat up to 1200 degrees Fahrenheit, meaning that you may safely set hot pans on them. If you do this with another countertop, you risk irreversible damage and discolouration. 

    For instance, quartz melts at temperatures above 300 degrees Fahrenheit.

    Even though granite can resist high temperatures, you should still use a heat mat or trivet to prevent damage to your counters.

    Scratch Resistant

    Granite counters are durable and won't scratch easily. Kitchen countertops are frequently used, so knives and other sharp tools will scratch them.

    Fortunately, granite countertops are scratch-resistant. They last longer and are more sturdy than nearly any other substance. 

    You may enjoy your granite counters for years, which will still appear brand new. Wooden and plastic laminate countertops also tend to show scratches easily.

    stonemason 27

    Disadvantages of Granite Countertops

    Granite countertops have many positive qualities, but there are also some drawbacks to consider before placing a large order.

    It is a complex renovation project to replace your countertops with granite. It's cumbersome and prone to cracking when worked on. More problems with granite are listed below.

    Appears to be out of date

    Darker granite countertop colours and patterns are particularly out of style at the moment. These days, it's all about clean lines and stark whites. Granite's inherent grains and veining prevent it from being dyed to a uniform colour (as is possible with quartz).

    Granite countertops are still in style, but if you plan to sell your home in the future, choosing a style that will appeal to the largest potential demographic is crucial.

    If potential buyers feel they need to renovate the kitchen because of the countertops, they may be dissuaded from making an offer.

    Busy Design

    There are better choices than Granite if you want your kitchen to have a sleek, contemporary appearance. Granite slabs can vary greatly in the intensity of their speckling and veining.

    Although many prefer this unaltered appearance, others find it detrimental. It is dependent upon the desired aesthetic.

    Prominent Seams are to Be Expected

    It will be necessary to cut and put the slabs together to create an L- or U-shaped design. As a result, the seams will be visible. 

    Even with the most skilled installers, seams will always be visible to some degree. 

    Of course, if you're using granite for your kitchen island's counter, you won't have to worry about this.

    Required Sealing

    Since granite is porous by nature, sealing it is a must. In most cases, the sealer will already be applied to the countertops by the manufacturer before installation.

    However, if the granite wasn't sealed to begin with, or if the seal wore off over time, it may soak up any liquids left on it.

    Repairing a seal is simple; stick to the manufacturer's guidelines. If you need additional instruction, you may find plenty of instructive videos online.

    Prone to Cracking

    Granite countertops might break if you accidentally drop a heavy object on them. Cast-iron skillets and other similarly hefty pots and pans require extra caution.

    Cracks in granite typically appear along its cut edges. Pay close attention to the area around the sink opening.

    If your granite becomes chipped or cracked, have it fixed by an expert. The manufacturer may patch the break with epoxy that matches the colour of the plastic.

    Quartz and marble, two popular countertops, have inherent breaking hazards. And although the possibility is low, exercise caution when moving big things.

    The tendency to fade

    As with other types of natural stone, granite loses its lustre with prolonged exposure to sunshine.

    Protect your granite countertop if you use it in an outdoor kitchen. Remember that the granite's initial gleam may gradually fade if you can't keep it out of the sun.

    Dyeing granite increases its susceptibility to fading.

    FAQs About Masonry

    Onyx countertops are generally more expensive than granite countertops due to their rarity and unique appearance.

    Yes, onyx countertops are often backlit to highlight their translucent qualities, creating a stunning visual effect.

    Granite typically offers a wider range of colour options, including various shades of black, white, grey, and numerous other natural hues. Onyx tends to have limited colour options, primarily in the white, beige, and pastel range.

    Granite countertops benefit from sealing to prevent stains and water absorption, while onyx countertops require sealing to a greater extent due to their more porous nature.

    Abrasive cleaners should be avoided on both granite and onyx countertops as they can scratch the surface. Instead, use a mild, non-abrasive cleaner for regular maintenance.

    Onyx Countertops: Maintenance Tips

    Unlike granite, onyx is easily scratched by everyday items, including cooking pots, cleaning detergents, cutlery, and acids. Locations with little traffic or usage should be prioritised for installation and upkeep. These are places like the counters at bars and bathrooms, which people tend to avoid. Because of its ever-shifting hues and contrasting veins, it works particularly well in such settings. Keeping food spills, toothpaste, and moisture away from the glass will help prevent stains. If any of them were spilt, they would have to be wiped up immediately to prevent stains. Surfaces require regular resealing as part of their upkeep.

    stonemason 12

    Maintaining Your Granite Kitchen Surfaces

    Care and maintenance are necessary to extend the life of and preserve the colour of any natural stone countertop. Granite, like other stones, should be sealed and cleaned regularly with stone cleaners to prevent stains. The material is dense, however, so it may not need to be sealed. If you want a countertop that can take the abuse of hot pots, sharp knives, and daily use, go no further than granite. Since they are stain-resistant, you can put them in the bathroom or bar. However, you shouldn't use acids or vinegar if you want them to last longer.

    Conclusion

    Choosing the right countertop material is crucial for improving the visual appeal of your kitchen or bathroom. Granite and onyx are popular choices due to their natural luxury and ability to be polished to achieve a marble-like sheen. Onyx is a unique and expensive option, but its high care requirements and difficult installation make it rarely used in kitchens and bathrooms.

    Onyx countertops offer several benefits, including their unique appearance, durability, and ease of carrying. They are versatile and can be found in various colors, such as yellow, green, blue, red, beige, and cream. They are also translucent, making them soft to the touch and suitable for backlighting to warm and brighten stone tones. However, onyx is rare and requires more maintenance than granite, which is more expensive due to its rarity and high demand.

    Onyx is fragile and requires constant upkeep, with fiberglass being used to reinforce the base but still prone to damage. Regular cleaning and sealing are also necessary to prevent scratches and stains.

    Granite, made up of plagioclase, quartz, and alkali feldspar, is a natural stone that offers long-lasting, hygienic, and aesthetically pleasing countertops. It is a natural material with no synthetic resins or additives, giving the space a cozy, opulent feel. It comes in various colors and patterns, offering a wide range of design possibilities that will complement your kitchen's style.

    Choosing the right countertop material is essential for enhancing the visual appeal of your kitchen or bathroom. While granite and onyx offer unique and beautiful options, it is important to weigh the pros and cons before making a decision.

    Granite countertops are aesthetically pleasing and functional, outperforming quartz and marble in heat resistance and durability. They can withstand temperatures up to 1200 degrees Fahrenheit, making them safe for hot pans. They are also scratch-resistant, making them last longer and more sturdy than wood or plastic laminate countertops. However, granite countertops have drawbacks, such as being complex to replace, appearing outdated, having a busy design, visible seams, and the need for sealing.

    Granite is porous, so sealing is essential, but if not done properly, it may soak up liquids. Cracks in granite can occur when heavy objects are dropped on them, and it is important to have the crack repaired by an expert. Onyx countertops, on the other hand, are easily scratched by everyday items, making them ideal for bars and bathrooms.

    To maintain granite kitchen surfaces, seal them with stone cleaners and avoid using acids or vinegar. Onyx countertops are ideal for areas with little traffic or usage, but should be cleaned regularly to prevent stains. Onyx countertops are also stain-resistant, making them suitable for use in bathrooms or bars.

    In conclusion, granite and onyx countertops are both durable and aesthetically pleasing, but they require proper maintenance to extend their lifespan and maintain their color.

    Content Summary:

    • Choosing the proper countertop material is essential if you want to improve the visual appeal of your kitchen or bathroom.
    • Countertops made of granite or onyx are typically the most expensive and eye-catching choices.
    •  We'll compare and contrast these two high-quality options here.
    • After reading this, your decision on how to proceed with your home renovation project will be well-informed.
    • Onyx is a popular alternative to marble for home decor because of its natural luxury and the fact that it can be polished to get a marble-like sheen.
    • If you own a home in Toronto and are debating whether or not to put in an onyx bar countertop, read on.
    • For your consideration are the following benefits and drawbacks.
    • Onyx is an excellent choice if you want a bar countertop made of natural stone but also something unique.
    • Onyx countertops are superior to other natural stone options due to their one-of-a-kind beauty.
    • You may use this quality to your advantage by lighting under the stone to create a backlit bar top.
    • Onyx is frequently employed in decorative contexts because of its lesser weight than other natural stones.
    • Due to its rarity and high demand, onyx is one of the most expensive natural stones for countertops.
    • Because you'll likely need to employ a contractor with experience working with the material, you should expect the cost of labour and installation to be higher.
    • This is necessary to protect the countertop from being harmed during the installation process.
    • It's also important to seal the countertop correctly to prevent damage.
    • There's more to it than merely dropping in an onyx slab for a bar top.
    • If you plan on using it as a bar top, kitchen counter, or bathroom vanity, seal it first.
    • Costs associated with having the countertop refinished regularly should be considered if regular use is planned.
    • Using onyx, an exotic natural stone, as a bar countertop may create a stunning statement.
    • If you install backlighting behind your onyx bar countertop, it will become the room's focal point.
    • Granite countertops are prefered because they are long-lasting, hygienic, and aesthetically pleasing.
    • In contrast, every component of granite is of natural origin.
    • All granite slabs are one-of-a-kind.
    • The natural stone finishings give the space a cosy, opulent feel reminiscent of a Tuscan villa or a French country house.
    • The nearly infinite possibilities in terms of design are one of granite's biggest benefits.
    • Because every slab of granite is one of a kind, it gives homeowners the chance to choose a one-of-a-kind accent for their homes.
    • The point is that granite affords a variety of design possibilities.
    • And there's bound to be something that works with the style of your kitchen.
    • Shopping for granite, however, is often the most thrilling part of a kitchen redesign for most individuals.
    • Granite is not only aesthetically pleasing but also functional.
    • It outperforms quartz and marble in terms of resistance to heat and durability.
    • For instance, quartz melts at temperatures above 300 degrees Fahrenheit.
    • Granite countertops have many positive qualities, but there are also some drawbacks to consider before placing a large order.
    • It is a complex renovation project to replace your countertops with granite.
    • More problems with granite are listed below.
    • Appears to be out of date Darker granite countertop colours and patterns are particularly out of style at the moment.
    • Granite countertops are still in style, but if you plan to sell your home in the future, choosing a style that will appeal to the largest potential demographic is crucial.
    • There are better choices than Granite if you want your kitchen to have a sleek, contemporary appearance.
    • It is dependent upon the desired aesthetic. As a result, the seams will be visible.
    • Of course, if you're using granite for your kitchen island's counter, you won't have to worry about this.
    • In most cases, the sealer will already be applied to the countertops by the manufacturer before installation.
    • Repairing a seal is simple; stick to the manufacturer's guidelines.
    • Quartz and marble, two popular countertops, have inherent breaking hazards.
    • The tendency to fade As with other types of natural stone, granite loses its lustre with prolonged exposure to sunshine.
    • Protect your granite countertop if you use it in an outdoor kitchen.
    • Remember that the granite's initial gleam may gradually fade if you can't keep it out of the sun.
    • Dyeing granite increases its susceptibility to fading.
    • Locations with little traffic or usage should be prioritised for installation and upkeep.
    • Keeping food spills, toothpaste, and moisture away from the glass will help prevent stains.
    • Care and maintenance are necessary to extend the life of and preserve the colour of any natural stone countertop.
    • Granite, like other stones, should be sealed and cleaned regularly with stone cleaners to prevent stains.
    • If you want a countertop that can take the abuse of hot pots, sharp knives, and daily use, go no further than granite.
    • Since they are stain-resistant, you can put them in the bathroom or bar.
    Scroll to Top